Wednesday, May 16, 2012

Week 7: Intelligence, Competence, and Ability

So for this week, I want to hear what you guys think about when people use the word "intelligence, competence, or ability". They might say, “Johnny is so smart!” or “My cousin has a disability” When they say Johnny is smart, do you think they mean intelligent? or competent? or able? Do these words kind of mean the same thing? Why or why not? From your guys' past experiences, do you think people use these words under the right circumstances? Can you give me an anecdote of what happened? Let me know if it doesn't make any sense. 

12 comments:

  1. When people say someone is smart, I think that they mean all intelligent, competent, and ability. The definition of smart depends on situation and to whom people are saying it to. For example, a young child might think that his older sister is smart because she can solve a subtraction problem that is hard for him to solve. However, a high school student may not think that the child’s sister is smart because he has more knowledge than her. I think that intelligent, competent, and ability are related to each other to provide similar meanings. But, I don’t think people use these words under the right circumstances. For example, I’ve hear many Korean parents talk about smart students around their neighborhood because education is really important in Korean culture. However, being smart mostly considers good grades or GPAs for those parents. Therefore, I think that some people have very narrow perspectives about being smart, intelligent, competent, or able.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I didn't realize how you looked at the definition of smart in that manner. It makes sense that all of them can be applied. I really like how you mentioned Korean culture as your example, as I can relate to that.

      Delete
    2. Going off of your little sibling example, the children that I babysit are a good example! The youngest is 4 and she thinks that her older sister is really smart but since I am older than her I would clearly be the smartest. Good example.

      Delete
  2. When someone uses the term "smart", I think that in this culture it usually means that the person being talked about is good at showing performance in academic matters and school. This definition can change pretty extremely if you look at another culture who may value being socially affable as being a measure of "smartness". When someone says that someone is disabled, I think it can span many different common meanings. "Disabled" could mean mental or physical disabilities and can span a huge spectrum of severity. I think that words like competent and able do differ from the word "intelligent" because being competent generally carries a different weight in our society than being "intelligent". I think you can be considered intelligent but not competent. Some people use the words under appropriate circumstances but I think, for the large part, depending on who you are, everyone can find a problem with the way that anyone labels someone else. The way we label people as "able" or "not able" or "smart" or "not smart" depend highly on the constructs of the society that we live in. For example, I think that the way that we label many of the socially different kids as "not smart" is wrong because they may just see the world differently than many people. But, someone who places a lot of value on the ability of someone to work as part of the whole effectively and comfortably as a sign of "smartness" would probably disagree with me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you that the definition of smart depends on culture and it usually represents people’s academic levels in our society. Although I think that intelligence, competence, and ability interact with each other, I also understand how you differentiated them.

      Delete
  3. Okay, so this happens a lot. I think that everyone is intelligent in their own way and about different subjects. To say that someone is smart means that they are doing well in that particular subject. If they are succeeding in multiple subjects then people would be more inclined to say that they are intelligent. I think there is a difference between the words ability, able and intelligence. Ability and able can refer to ones own capability to do a certain skill. While intelligence can be something comparable to other people. You are ranked based on your knowledge of a skill. I am not sure if I just went in a circle with that but it makes sense to me! I remember being in middle school and having a teacher say you're so smart! I got an A on an assignment in a subject that I enjoyed but then when I didn't get an A I got no praise. I think that a lot of people refer to good grades as intelligent.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree that many people today consider good grades as being intelligent. However, people have different skills in different areas as you said. I think that people should focus more on an individual’s abilities/skills rather than their intelligence.

      Delete
    2. I really like how you mentioned grades as a type of assessment for people to make on smartness. I agree that this is not everything and that people have their own strengths and weaknesses and should not be defined by these specific qualities.

      Delete
    3. Yes, I agree that many people assign intelligence to grades. I think this is a hard thing to get over as so much of our formidable years are spent being graded and measured, it just gets driven into peoples' heads that grades are the measure of intelligence. I don't think that is always necessarily true, though. Someone can not understand how to do something and still get a good grade through luck while someone who really does understand the concept gets a bad grade through misunderstanding or test anxiety.

      Delete
  4. I think that when people use smart in this way they are referring to intelligence and knowledge. When people use "smart" casually, they are thinking about the different things that people do in order to prove that they know something. I do not think that all of the words mean the same thing, because in different circumstances you are going to face situations where you understand something or not. Therefore, judgement cannot be made so quickly as to what kind of "smartness" someone has. I think that many people use the work disability and handicapped inappropriately. Then again, it is only in my understanding that this is "inappropriate" because people may have learned certain words in different ways. I believe that disability is just a certain think that you are not able to do (and all people have), but it should not define who you are. The same thing goes with intelligence and how people are labeled as either "smart" or "dumb"

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with your assessment of "smartness" across different situations. I think that some types of smartness are valued higher then others in various societies but that many types of "smartness" are necessary to make a society work. In this country, for instance, many people consider those who are good at academic tasks like calculus and chemistry to be very smart while someone who is good at being a mechanic may not be considered as intelligent. Neither of these professions are "smarter" than the other, though, they are simply different types of smartness.

      Delete
    2. Yeah, someone can be smart in one subject but not know anything in another subject! I can't stop thinking about Ross from friends! :)

      Delete