Wednesday, May 2, 2012
Week 5: Development
So for this week, since the topic is "Development", I'm curious to know, what do you guys think the difference between learning and developing? How are they similar? How are they different? Does culture affect development differently than it affects learning? How does culture play a role in this matter? Also, you could think about this week's blog as an extensive blog or an addition to last week's blog (last week's was about sociocultural theory and this week is about cultural development). Just to keep in mind, there's no right or wrong answer, I would just like to know what you guys think about this.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I agree with sociocultural theorists that “learning and development are two different processes that are complexly related to each other” (Bodrova & Leong, 12). I think that learning is understanding and constructing new knowledge using your prior knowledge that is gained from external resources or cultural environments. On the other hand, I think that development is maturation or change of your external and internal appearances/minds. Although they are different processes, learning and development are similar because they improve your abilities both physically and mentally.
ReplyDeleteI think that culture affects development differently than it affects learning because people become members of their own cultural communities as they develop. Therefore, development significantly depends on where you grow up. As we saw on the Babies movie, people develop completely different because of the environments and cultural practices.
I like how your referenced the text and really connected the topic to last week's theory so directly. Your learning definition is very interesting and has created new light in the topic. The Babies movie is a perfect example of environments and cultural practices which impacts both learning and development!
DeleteI agree that development is affected in much different way that learning by the culture that you grow up in. We develop according to our own culture and learn things to assimilate into that developed schema. Also, the meaning of development depends largely on the culture that you are in as one place may consider developmental milestones to be quite different that another place. Just because we think babies shouldn't be aloud to play with knives doesn't mean that another culture should think that it's strange.
DeleteI think that development and learning are different processes but are also interconnected. Learning is the process by which we take in new information and add that information to our schema. Development is more transformative as it is the process where your schema itself matures through time. We learn according to our own cultures and we also develop according to our own cultures. We learn things through our cultural lens and then mature according to our cultural expectations. Development relies very much on where a person grows up as the standards of development change according to local culture.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your points of how development and learning are interconnected. I find you definition of development very interesting and has helped me look into it in a different light. Our lens do impact our own schema and can be a great indicator for different learning or development processes.
DeleteI also think that they are interconnected. It is hard to have one without the other.
DeleteI think that development and learning are different but at the same time they work together and development can be a part of my real learning definition. It kind of works as indicators if someone is learning something. They are different in the sense that they express different things. Development is very broad and it can go from mental development to actual physical development. Learning on the other hand is more of a mental process that can be expressed physically. I also believe that this week's readings and topic really intertwines with last week's topic of the socialcultural theory.
ReplyDeleteI do agree with what you have said about the difference and similarities about learning and development. I was having trouble putting my thoughts into words but I think you did a good job at stating the difference between the two.
DeleteI agree with your definitions of development and learning. I also think that development can be both physical and mental, but learning is more like mental process. Interaction of development and learning is significant in our lives.
DeleteI think that development and learning are different to an extent. Learning and development can happen everyone. One can learn about a culture by being submerged in that culture. One can also develop in a culture. Gaining the cultures beliefs, morals and ideas. Someone can develop in a culture that is different from what they grew up with as well. It is hard for me to make these two concepts have different definitions because I think it is difficult to have a clear line between both.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that learning and development are difficult to define since they interact with each other. I also think that people learn a lot both from their own and others' cultures.
DeleteIt's an interesting idea to say that you develop within your own culture and learn about other cultures. I wonder if this is a good explanation of the fundamental difference between development and learning? Is it possible to completely switch into another cultural development?
Delete