Wednesday, April 4, 2012

Week 1: Mastery vs. Understanding.

For this week, I want to know what you guys think of mastery and understanding. How are they different? Are they the same in any way? What are the benefits and flaws for "mastery"? What are the benefits and flaws for "understanding"? And lastly, can you guys think and tell me of an experience that you guys had in your life where you used "mastery" and "understanding"?

16 comments:

  1. I think that mastery and understanding are different in that mastery only asks for a mastery of the subject insofar as being able to always get the right answer to a problem while understanding requires that you understand the concepts behind the problem that you are solving. One can have a mastery of a subject as well as an understanding, but they can also exist exclusively from each other. One very big benefit of understanding is that it usually follows that having an understanding of a problem will also allow you to have mastery of the problem. Understanding can be less important than mastery in some instances, though. For example, while having an understanding of how to work out 6x6 with manipulatives or pictures can be very helpful, it is probably more important to have a mastery of that problem and thus just be able to say the answer from memory, or through mastery. In my own life, I use both mastery and understanding extensively from day to day. When I go to the grocery store and the clerk tells me my groceries are $10.50, I can take out the ten dollar bill and the two quarters to pay with because I have a mastery of what those symbols mean in relation to money amounts. When I work on my weaving I know how to press the treadles down in order to make the pattern I want, which is mastery, but I also know how the weave is structured and how to set up the treadles to achieve the pattern I want, which is understanding. If I didn't set up my own loom and was just told to sit down and press the treadles in a certain order, I could do it and it would make the right woven pattern. In order to fix an unexpected mechanical mistake, however, or fix a broken thread, I need to know how the entire process and structure of the pattern that I am working on is set up. I think this is a good example of why understanding is ultimately more important than mastery. Mastery is all well and good until something unexpected happens or something goes wrong while understanding allows you to address the situation and alter your thinking so that you can move on with the problem.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you that understanding allows you to gain mastery. Although mastery is important for specific learning such as math like you said in your grocery example, I also think that understanding is more important than mastery.

      Delete
    2. I think it is really interesting that you used weaving as an example. Since this is a hobby of yours you are really able to explain and understand all of the concepts about the subject. I feel like it would be difficult to weave if one did not understand and master the skills needed.

      Delete
    3. I think you bring a good point into understanding these concepts. Your example of the grocery store is interesting and I can kind of see how that applies to mastery and understanding. I think your statement on how "master is all well and good until..." is a good point as to why mastery can work sometimes, but not all the time! It makes me wonder about the different concepts we are learning and what "real learning" is.

      Delete
  2. I think that mastery and understanding are two very different ideas, but at the same time very difficult to understand. It was interesting to learn about the two concepts, because it seemed like I knew what they meant, but when Kendall asked us to represent them, I (and our group) had a hard time trying to explain and represent it. I think that they are the same because you can learn something out of both of them. Before the class, it didn't occur to me that mastery was also learning, but in some sense I can say that it is learning. They are different because they are two totally different ways of learning. I think that understanding is a part of my definition of "real learning".

    I think that the benefits of mastery, is that it can be used in a way where people do not need to know the whole concept of where something comes from. It is simple in itself and therefore allows a person to accomplish a given task. On the other hand, it is flawed because it leaves little room for growth and to carry on the topic at a greater level. On the other hand, when you understand something you use the knowledge on a deeper level, and are able to apply the skills later. Since you know more about a subject thoroughly, you are able to use that for further knowledge. Understanding is flawed, because it does require a lot of time, and sometimes it is unnecessary to accomplish a given task.

    I have experienced mastery, when I speak Korean. It is just something that I caught onto from my parents and it isn't something I know the background knowledge to. I don't know how the words form together and make a meaning, I just understand it as a sound and a definition that matches that sound. I have mastered Korean in the sense, that I know how to communicate, but I don't know the deeper meanings and understandings of the language. I have experienced understanding when I experience different interactions with people. It is hard to experience something that I have understood, because many times it is subtle. But I think that through my interactions with people (social life), I am able to understand more about people and especially my friends. When it comes to situations where we fight or disagree, I can use my prior understandings of that person to get over the current situation.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree that learning through understanding takes a lot of time, sometimes worthless. I like your personal experience of understanding. I also try to overcome disagreements through the same way, but sometimes it's just hard to understand.

      Delete
    2. I really like your personal accounts of mastery vs. understanding. Applying the concept of understanding to personal relationships is a very simple and elegant way to explain what it truly means to understand a concept or a situation. After all, how could we ever solve our differences with our friends without having a deeper understanding of the conflict and the person? I also agree with you about the unfortunate drawback of understanding in that it takes so much longer to learn through understanding than through mastery. I think the question then lies in whether it is better to take longer and really understand something or to learn something quickly without having a clear understanding about what you just learned.

      Delete
  3. I think that mastery and understanding are different concepts for learning. As we talked during the meeting on Tuesday, mastery refers to memorization and getting correct answers. On the other hand, understanding is like absorbing a specific knowledge that can be applied later for the same or different purpose. Although they are more different from each other, mastery and understanding both teach new information to people.

    One of the benefits for mastery is that people can be professionals and make fewer mistakes. Since they know the right answers from the memorization, they would be able to answer specific questions right away. However, the flaw for mastery is that people might forget the information they’ve memorized if they do not use the knowledge constantly. Therefore, it will be difficult to apply to other circumstances if they only memorized that one correct answer. On the other hand, understanding can be beneficial because people really know what they’ve learned. So, they can apply their knowledge later or teach to others. But, understanding can be flawed because sometimes people just need to memorize certain information or knowledge. Also, understanding needs more explanation and practice to understand better.

    I use both mastery and understanding when I drive. If I need to get to the destination where I know very well such as my house, I just need to use my memorized direction. I do not need to think about where to turn or stop because I have mastered driving to places where I go often. However, driving to new places is when I have to use understanding because I need to apply my knowledge and skills. I need to know how to read a map, find certain streets, or use GPS when I don’t know how to drive to new destinations. Or, I could try to remember how I went to that place last time (if I’ve been there once) and apply to current situation.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with what you said about mastering in driving skills. It is really interesting to think about the amount of energy that you used to drive to a familiar place. When compared to how stressful driving somewhere new can be it is easy to see the difference in focus level.

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    3. I can relate to your example of how mastery and understanding apply to driving. It also relates to what I said to Shannon above, that there are certain ways to use mastery and understanding. I had a bias that understanding is "better" that mastery, but there are times when mastery can be useful.

      Delete
  4. My definition of mastery is being able to complete a task while not necessarily fully comprehending what steps were being taken. To put this into context when I was taking a statistics class I simply memorized formulas. I would not be able to explain how or why I used that particular formula, all I know is what formula to use for a certain problem. The benefits of mastery would be that you don't really need to know the small details in order to succeed in a subject. While a flaw would be that since you may not really understand the subject you are more likely to forget the material once you stop using it everyday.

    My definition for understanding is when you are fully able to explain and use the knowledge given in the future. An example of understanding for me would be making coffee. My job as barista is to know the recipes and to understand why we do and use certain ingredients. A benefit of understanding is that you fully understand and grasp a topic. You are able to use the information that you learned in future context. I do not think that there are any major flaws with understanding.

    I think that mastery and understanding could be similar to an extent. They both share the common interest of learning something new. However, with that said you do not necessarily need to fully understand what is being asked of you.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I certainly agree with you about memorizing formulas. I also took statistics in high school, but I do not remember anything. When I was taking the class, I just memorized formulas because I could not understand any concepts.

      Delete
    2. I also agree about the problem of memorizing formulas in math classes without understanding them. I know I learned how to solve integrals while I was in Calculus in high school and that I solved many of those problems to get the right answer. But I cannot, for the life of me, remember how to do them now or tell you why I was ever doing them in the first place. They were just formulas I had to memorize to get through homework. I think that maybe this concept of "mastery-only" learning might be more prevalent in math than in other classes. It just seems like a good deal of the time when you ask someone to give an example of mastery without understanding the first thing that comes to the person's mind has to do with math problems. Of course mastery without understanding exists in other types of subjects, but it seems to be rampant in math.

      Delete
  5. Great job group 6! Thanks for posting. Don't forget to comment on each others posts :)

    -Arielle

    ReplyDelete