Wednesday, April 11, 2012

Week 2: Constructivism

So for this week, I'm curious to know of what your guys' take on this... What is the role of the teacher and student when knowledge is being constructed? Think about Melissa and her teacher when answering this question (I believe this was on Cobb's reading)... and can you think of your experience where this similarly happened to you? Feel free to write freely and reflect on your daily experience as much as you would like. Shoot me any questions if you need any clarifications.  

12 comments:

  1. I think that the role of the teacher and the role of the student while constructing knowledge are complimentary. The learning process will go smoother if they are each aware of the other's role in the process, although that is not generally the case. In the Melissa example, the teacher knows that Melissa has constructed her own way of doing subtraction problems that works juts fine for numbers below 15 but that will not serve her well for larger numbers. He wants to teach her to count backwards but he knows that the learning process of overcoming her old way of subtracting will not be especially easy. Because Melissa already has a "subtraction schema" in her head, she has to assimilate the new information into that pre-existing schema so that she can fully understand and accommodate the "counting backwards" lesson into how she understands subtraction. So, the teacher's role in this process is to provide information on counting backwards to Melissa and then let her work that information into her schema. He does this by making suggestions and giving her problems that encourage her to count backwards but he doesn't directly insist on it. If he were to directly insist on it, Melissa might be able to count backwards and give him the answer he is looking for, but she may not understand how she got to that new subtraction method. The teacher is there to help Melissa negotiate a new way of subtracting without imposing the new method on her so that she will just to it to make him happy. Melissa's roll in the process is to think about the information that is being given to her and to work that information over in her mind to make sense of it. She has to try to make connections in her mind and assimilate the information so that she can utilize the new method being taught to her successfully. She should also feel free to ask questions and request further explanation from her teacher.

    I have experienced this type of teacher-student learning process rather recently in a class I am taking right now, Math for Elementary School Teachers. The class focuses a lot on getting to the conceptual root behind familiar algorithms so that we can understand the whole subject clearly and so that we will be better prepared to help young students learn about math in the future. Our professor is very clear in her goals of guiding us to the right answers while actively expecting us to "wrestle with" concepts that we are exploring. I have found that, while it is sometimes frustrating to be stuck on a problem, it really does help to understand how I got the answer if I'm required to struggle with it instead of just being given a formula to figure it out.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think that your ideas and explanations on Melissa are very detailed and have helped me look at the teacher's role at a different perspective. I read this after my post on purpose so that my thoughts would not be swayed, but I think you did a good job of using Melissa as evidence on what a teacher's role is. With that said, I think that your experience plays a good role in a teacher's role and your understanding on what is needed to help a child learn.

      Delete
    2. I also think that Melissa’s teacher did a good job of teaching Melissa to understand the ideas about subtraction. If he made Melissa stop using her finger method, she might have been lost or did not completely understand the new method. I also agree with your experience because when I was taking a math class, I learned more with the problems that I’ve struggled with.

      Delete
  2. I think that a teacher's main role is to support the students in their constructive learning. As we talked about in class, I don't think that all people are made the same and that they come into a classroom as "blank slates". Every child has encountered their own understandings and concepts even in preschool. It we suspect that all we can do is "pour knowledge into their brains" then I think that as a teacher we would not be allowing the child to grow to their full potential. In Melissa's example, I think that by questioning her and her ways the teacher was allowing her to build her own thoughts and concepts of subtraction. This also ties into the concept of understanding. If the teacher told Melissa she was wrong and that she needed to apply subtraction in a certain way, Melissa may have not understood the concept and made it her own.

    I think that we are experiencing a lot of this in the classroom. By allowing us to think of the concepts before we hear the professionals talk about it, Kendall is allowing us to understand these concepts into our own personal schema. This is so important because all students are different and their prior knowledge and beliefs cannot be persuaded as either right or wrong. If it was then I do not think that the student can learn to their full potential.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. (Commenting about your second paragraph) I do think it is really cool that we go into lectures not knowing exactly what we are in for. Having to come up with our own ideas about a subject or concept is something that I haven't experienced before. Since most teachers want you to be prepared about a subject. It is refreshing to learn in a different way!

      Delete
    2. I agree that the idea of simply "pouring" information into children's brains isn't nearly constructive enough to really foster learning. Unfortunately this seems to still be the prevailing view on how education is supposed to work in this country. For example, that was one of the main complaints that I heard from people in the education profession about the movie "Waiting for Superman". I haven't seen it, but from what I've heard, it tends to represent teaching as something as simple as transmitting information from the teacher to the student.

      I also really like that we experience ideas on our own without having first read the professional literature on them. I think it helps to work the new ideas into my own way of thinking.

      Delete
  3. From my own experience I can tell you that pouring information out for students to simply absorb is not always the best strategy. I had a class last quarter where my teacher would lecture for 2 hours non-stop. No questions were asked during the lecture or anything! Then at the end of lecture everyone was so overwhelmed with the amount of information that was given to us that we were all basically red in the face and wanting to run away!

    What I am trying to get to is that teachers need to really pay attention to how all of the students learn. By mixing up different ways of teaching a subject. That way more people could have the opportunity to learn something!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with what you said in the second paragraph. It is because so many of the children come into the class with their own schema and strategies that it is difficult to find one way that works for teaching all children. It is a good idea that a teacher gets the chance to know their students and how they learn best and use these different techniques so benefit as much as possible for all children. Thanks for your thoughts they are very interesting.

      Delete
    2. I totally agree with your experience! Since I came to college and listening to the lectures, sometimes I also wonder if everyone’s actually learning. Teachers provide a lot of knowledge and students need to take in and comprehend what they are learning. Therefore, both teachers and students need to understand what their roles are.

      Delete
  4. I think that the role of the teacher is to give appropriate and new knowledge to the students. Then, the student’s role is to build that knowledge onto the prior knowledge. In this way, the student can use different knowledge to apply for various purposes. If the teacher and the student consider their roles carefully and understand each other, constructing knowledge will benefit both of them. According to Melissa’s case, I think that her teacher did a great job of teaching the knowledge of counting backwards. He did not restrict Melissa from using her fingers when solving subtraction problems. The teacher allowed Melissa to solve the questions that she could answer from using her fingers on her own. Then, he let Melissa use counting backwards technique when she could not use her imaginary fingers because the numbers were too big. Although Melissa had hard time counting backwards, she gradually started to remember that she has the new knowledge. Therefore, I think that Melissa and her teacher both successfully learned and taught knowledge.

    I had a similar experience when I moved to America. Although I studied English in Korea, I could not use most of my prior knowledge because American English is completely different. Therefore, I started to add new knowledge about English vocabularies, pronunciations, grammar structures, etc. However, I did not just use what I was learning in America. I tried to incorporate my prior knowledge, so I could understand better and build on my knowledge.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I like your example of your experience in learning English in America. I think that it represents the idea of schema really well. When people come to a different country or learn a new language, they are not just putting information about that country or language into an empty space in their brains, they have to incorporate and build off of previous knowledge. We can only learn new ideas by understanding them in a way that works with or changes what is already in our minds.

      Delete
    2. That is a good example of how you had to construct your own knowledge. Being forced into a culture that uses mostly one language is a good way to really gain more knowledge on that culture and how they use language.

      Delete